I am normally a lurker, but I do thank and appreciate the
admin as well. However, I think he/she touched on one of the
problems below when (s)he said "much of it in private
dealings." I believe if less of the dealings were private,
some of the "all pigs not being equal" perception would
disappear (or, less likely, bear itself out) From what little is made
public, that perception appears justified ...
I believe that handling all administrative matters publicly would
be a lot worse. It could unnecessarily embarrass some minor
offenders and would be undesirably disruptive.
There does appear to be some "ineptitude", to use Admin's
word, on, for instance, what is considered an NPC, what
threads get moved, and who does/does not get
warned/disciplined. But maybe there isn't, and maybe if the
membership knew more about what was going on, we would have
a better idea.
From vpFREE Rules and Policies: "The vpFREE Administrative
Committee (a Dictatorship, hopefully benevolent) makes, interprets
and enforces the rules and policies for vpFREE."
In practice this responsibility is delegated to the Administrator.
I'm receptive to suggestions and questions about how the forums are
and should be run (use private email or post on FREEvpFREE),
but I don't intend to keep the membership informed about routine
administrative actions unless I consider it advisable. If this decreases
my approval rating, I can live with that.
It's not easy playing Solomon and it's often difficult to judge what
would have been the best course of action, even after the fact. I
make vpFREE decisions based on what I believe to be right and
fair and I'm satisfied with my performance.
I believe that the Admin's desires to remain anonymous and
to make arbitrary decisions on which disciplinary actions
do/do not become public come with a price -- that price
being the heartache so sincerely and eloquently expressed
below.
IMO the price would be a lot greater if my identity were known and
if all administrative decisions were decided by polling the members.
I'm posting this on FREEvpFREE also, where any responses to this
post should be made. Please use private email or FREEvpFREE for
all comments or discussions about how the forums are run.
vpFREE Administrator
ยทยทยท
On 24 Nov 2005 at 9:50, Mark wrote: