vpFREE2 Forums

Use of the word "Indian"

Native Americans. This is a stupid subject for a VP board. What's
next politics or religion?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~`

I don't care, you go ahead and lead off......

SK

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

···

From: "bolo662002" <bolo66@swbell.net>
What a STUPID thread! When I was a kid I used to play Cowboys and

golden bearpa wrote:

>What a STUPID thread! When I was a kid I used to play Cowboys and
Native Americans. This is a stupid subject for a VP board.

I agree, and extend my apologies for extending the thread.

But I hope you'll allow me to offer up a bit of explanatory fluff as
to why, as someone else essentially pointed out to me privately, I
seem to be a little more huffed up about the topic than Native
Americans/Indians themselves.

You just gotta get that having never been to the Caucausus region and
having a complexion that is far from milky white, I'm compelled when
asked on a form for Race to check "Other" and fill in "pale face".

- H.

···

>From: "bolo662002" <bolo66@s...>

I noticed that my last message did not come through so I am resending it.

In Canada, we do not use the word Indian-we call people who came from India, "East Indian" - we refer to Indians as "Native" not "Native Canadian", just native. It is considered derogatory to call them Indian (in Canada that is). As well we never use the word Eskimo, (it is considered derogatory) we call them "Inuit" . So now I wonder if Native Americans would prefer to be called "Native", as opposed to "Indian" or "Native American".

Myra

···

On 16-Aug-04, at 6:09 PM, John Kelly wrote:

You're right, Jean.

Michelle doesn't mind "Indian" a bit, and I don't know of any Native
Americans that do. Obviously, a few DO mind the term, but they're in the
vast minority as far as I can tell. For most, it's just not a big deal.
Native American, "Injun", whatever. Besides, being named after people
who live on the other side of the planet is small price to pay for the
everlasting reminder that Columbus was hopelessly lost.

John

On 17-Aug-04, at 3:50 PM, Harry Porter wrote:

golden bearpa wrote:

From: "bolo662002" <bolo66@s...>
What a STUPID thread! When I was a kid I used to play Cowboys and

Native Americans. This is a stupid subject for a VP board.

I agree, and extend my apologies for extending the thread.

But I hope you'll allow me to offer up a bit of explanatory fluff as
to why, as someone else essentially pointed out to me privately, I
seem to be a little more huffed up about the topic than Native
Americans/Indians themselves.

You just gotta get that having never been to the Caucausus region and
having a complexion that is far from milky white, I'm compelled when
asked on a form for Race to check "Other" and fill in "pale face".

- H.

vpFREE Links: http://members.cox.net/vpfree/Links.htm

Yahoo! Groups Links