we all know that Bob Dancer is the ONLY knowledgable player but do
we have to keep reading comments by him that totally belittle the
only contrubutors the the video poker society. when will the
administrator finally have enough of this ego-maniac?
I doubt this very much. Writing a good beginner's book is a worthy
goal.
If others want to write a book with another goal, that's their
privilege. My criticism of Jean has never been with her goals, but
rather that she lacks the expertise to write a good beginner's
book.
After reading this book, my opinion remains the same.
Jean's book has numerous flaws, including several irresponsible
statements. Any beginner who believes that all of the advice in
the book
is worth following will be making a big, expensive, mistake. If
you know
how to pick and choose the good from the bad, she states a lot of
basic
information reasonably well. But one of the definitions of a
beginner is
that they do NOT know how to pick and choose between the good
statements
and the irresponsible ones. That makes her book dangerous.
One (of several) mistatements is that if you use 9/6 Jacks
strategy on
Super Double Bonus, the return will be greater than 99.6%. (She
actually
credits/blames Skip Hughes for this information). Had she/he said
9/5
SDB, then the information would have been correct. But I suspect at
least 90% of all SDB games out there are 8/5 or 7/5. Using 9/6
Jacks
strategy on these games will yield a return of far less than
99.6%. An
advanced player might be expected to figure out that Jean/Skip
were only
referring to 9/5 SDB, but a beginning player would not know this.
This
beginner could play at a casino that has no good games in it at
all, so
they can't find 9/6 Jacks, but the casino might well have 7/5 SDB
(a
97.8% game when played perfectly). Jean's book says that if you
use 9/6
Jacks strategy on this 97.8% game, the game automatically becomes
worth
99.6%. I call this irresponsible. And that is definitely NOT the
only
such statement.
At the end of her book, she claims that if you master it, you'll
be one
player in 10,000. Yeah, right. Mastering ANY beginner's book will
put
you in the top 10%-20% or so, but certainly not in the range she
claims.
Although the bankroll numbers from Michael Shackleford in the book
are
useful, there is nothing else in it that most people on vpFREE
don't
already know. If you're a big Jean Scott fan (and she has more
fans on
this site than I do), go ahead and get the book. You know you're
going
to do it anyway, no matter what I say. If you don't know her books,
though, I suggest you read the critiques on Amazon.com to find out
what
many others believe about her writings before you fork out good
money
for this one. These reviews will tell you, each in their own way,
that
if you can already find your way out of a paper bag, Jean's books
have
···
no useful information in them for you.
Bob Dancer
For the best in video poker information, visit www.bobdancer.com
or call 1-800-244-2224 M-F 9-5 Pacific Time.