5a. Re: Do Casinos Punish Lucky Players?
Date: Mon Jun 18, 2007 9:14 pm ((PDT))Not VP, but the Mirage is not a sweat shop.
I had a session at Mirage a while back where I won
over $25,000 playing blackjack. I am sure they
tracked my play through the eye but either they just
tolerated my play or I fooled their program. Anyway,
I got a good number of decent offers from them and had
no problems when I took them up on an offer. Since
blackjack players come under higher scrutiny than VP
players for advantage play, I think it was just a
marketing screw up that you did not receive offers.
I had the same experience with unexpectedly high incidence of winning trips at blackjack at Treasure Island long ago, although none as high an individual trip win as described above. After ten years of card-counting, I was finally barred, just when I was thinking they didn't really care if I counted cards at all!
The barring extended to all their properties, but only for blackjack. In fact, that's when I stepped up my level of VP play, and I continued to be treated well, just not allowed to play blackjack.
I had been going three to five times a year and winning 80% of the trips, at a high level of play. I was pretty sure that they would have noticed, and was in fact surprised it took so long, once I knew that it DID make a difference to them -- of course, it's possible that new management changed the attitude toward card counters, who knows.
But I agree that on games where the house has the edge and the player can't do SIGNIFICANT damage to the house with expert play, they probably don't sweat it much, esp. in the short run.
Certainly if they are telling the truth about the mailing problem, they will be able to fix it, and in fact will restore offers that were returned in the mail (I've contacted a casino where I got an offer by bulk mail after it expired, and they "made good" on it on my next visit). If they don't fix it after a reasonable effort on your part to point our the mailing problem, then I guess in your case, you made somebody unhappy 
--BG
···
==================