vpFREE2 Forums

6% surcharge PLUS 1% EXTRA SALES TAX????

No, not for the tribe to charge its own tax, but that is not the case here from what I understand by what the state told me. This is a state tax that is being charged not a casino tax. By the state law, there is no tax on bullion over $1000. If the casino itself is charging tax on these bars of gold, which I doubt, then it is odd that that is the only thing they are charging a casino tax on, (other than Indian made items which the state does not get the tax on). And if they are charging a tax on these Swiss bars on their own, it may still be illegal according to state law. That is what FW is trying to do by adding a 1% tax to everything, and the state said FW would have to get permission from the state to do that, and it has not, so they are looking into it. Someone has to protect the citizens from unfair taxing. Ha, it is almost a joke to say that. :^)
John

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Interesting...keep us updated on your quest.

Cogno

···

-----Original Message-----
From: vpFREE_NewEngland@yahoogroups.com
[mailto:vpFREE_NewEngl…@…com] On Behalf Of John
Sent: Friday, September 11, 2009 7:19 AM
To: vpFREE_NewEngland@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [vpFREE_NewEngland] Re: 6% surcharge PLUS 1% EXTRA SALES
TAX???

No, not for the tribe to charge its own tax, but that is not the case
here from what I understand by what the state told me. This is a state
tax that is being charged not a casino tax. By the state law, there is
no tax on bullion over $1000. If the casino itself is charging tax on
these bars of gold, which I doubt, then it is odd that that is the only
thing they are charging a casino tax on, (other than Indian made items
which the state does not get the tax on). And if they are charging a
tax on these Swiss bars on their own, it may still be illegal according
to state law. That is what FW is trying to do by adding a 1% tax to
everything, and the state said FW would have to get permission from the
state to do that, and it has not, so they are looking into it. Someone
has to protect the citizens from unfair taxing. Ha, it is almost a joke
to say that. :^)
John

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

------------------------------------

vpFREE Links: http://members.cox.net/vpfree/Links.htm
Yahoo! Groups Links

Interesting...keep us updated on your quest.

Cogno

Ok, here is the deal now. The state sent me a form (AU-524) to get filled out by 'the retailer', (Oh Yea), which I then send back to the state for the tax refund. Now you know, that the store is not going to sign anything that is going to admit that they have charged a illegal tax on these bars. This is just some silly state paper, which as usual, makes everything more complicated than it should have to be. Fat chance I will ever get a refund on this, as she made it sound like I was at a dead end if this paper was not filed out by the owner or manager of the store. I talked to a Revenue Examiner for several minutes and explained that I thought there would be no way the store manager would sign this paper, as it would mean many other people would be bringing the same papers in and it might mean a problem for them in the future as a sort of admission of wrong doing.
I might just take it to the store and see what they say or do, but I sure don't expect they will fill in their part and sign it. The state now knows we are being charged the tax, it has been paid to the state for quite some time now, and basicly, it seems they are making it difficult to get our money back, they probably don't want to give the money back as the state 'needs it'. (if everyone who bought the bars requested a refund, it would mean thousands of dollars)

···

--- In vpFREE_NewEngland@yahoogroups.com, "Cogno Scienti" <cognoscienti@...> wrote:

> -----Original Message-----
> From: vpFREE_NewEngland@yahoogroups.com
> [mailto:vpFREE_NewEngl…@…com] On Behalf Of John
> Sent: Friday, September 11, 2009 7:19 AM
> To: vpFREE_NewEngland@yahoogroups.com
> Subject: [vpFREE_NewEngland] Re: 6% surcharge PLUS 1% EXTRA SALES
> TAX???
>
> No, not for the tribe to charge its own tax, but that is not the case
> here from what I understand by what the state told me. This is a state
> tax that is being charged not a casino tax. By the state law, there is
> no tax on bullion over $1000. If the casino itself is charging tax on
> these bars of gold, which I doubt, then it is odd that that is the only
> thing they are charging a casino tax on, (other than Indian made items
> which the state does not get the tax on). And if they are charging a
> tax on these Swiss bars on their own, it may still be illegal according
> to state law. That is what FW is trying to do by adding a 1% tax to
> everything, and the state said FW would have to get permission from the
> state to do that, and it has not, so they are looking into it. Someone
> has to protect the citizens from unfair taxing. Ha, it is almost a joke
> to say that. :^)
> John
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> vpFREE Links: http://members.cox.net/vpfree/Links.htm
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>